HyreCar vs. Turo: Where to Rent Your Next Car?

An Overview of HyreCar vs Turo

Overview of HyreCar

HyreCar stands out as a major player in the car-sharing industry, distinguishing itself by catering specifically to rideshare drivers employed by companies like Uber, Lyft, and DoorDash.

This innovative approach not only allows car owners to earn additional income but also enables individuals without cars to participate in the burgeoning gig economy.

The process of renting is designed for ease and efficiency, ensuring that renters can quickly start their gig-related tasks, such as making deliveries for Uber Eats. This creates a mutually beneficial scenario for both car owners and renters.

Overview of Turo

Turo sets itself apart by focusing on individuals who prefer personal driving experiences, unlike HyreCar, which is more aligned with rideshare drivers.

Turo understands the unique appeal of being behind the wheel, offering a sense of control and personal freedom that services like Uber and Lyft can’t match.

The platform caters to those who value the autonomy of managing their own routes and schedules, free from the unpredictability of a rideshare driver’s availability or route choices.

Turo’s distinct advantage lies in its diverse vehicle selection, ranging from eco-friendly hybrids to high-performance sports cars, catering to various preferences and occasions.

This service is ideal for anyone desiring the liberty of self-driven journeys, with the added luxury of choosing from an array of top-tier vehicles.

Key Differences Between HyreCar and Turo

Although both companies are in the car-sharing business, HyreCar and Turo offer different experiences. They have different insurance policies and eligibility requirements, too.

So, before we get to the specifics, let’s cover the basic groundwork.

Insurance Policies

Having insurance coverage encourages you to rent cars confidently. You want to understand both companies’ policies before you choose which one to rent from.

Turo Insurance Policies

Turo doesn’t provide insurance automatically, which is probably their biggest downside. If you have insurance yourself, they can offer protective plans that you can accept or decline. These include:

Plan	60 plan	75 plan	80 plan	85 plan	90 plan
Host take	60% of the trip price	75% of the trip price	80% of the trip price	85% of the trip price	90% of the trip price
Liability coverage	$750,000	$750,000	$750,000	$750,000	$750,000
Exterior wear-and-tear	Not covered	Not covered	Not covered	Not covered	Not covered
Deductible for physical damage	$0	$250	$750	$1,625	$2,500
Replacement vehicle reimbursement costs	$50 a day (up to 10 days)	$30 a day (up to 10 days)	Not covered	Not covered	Not covered
Loss of hosting income during repairs	Turo is responsible, or the host can have a ten-day Replacement vehicle reimbursement	Not covered	Not covered	Not covered	Not covered

HyreCar Insurance Policies

Unlike Turo, HyreCar offers comprehensive insurance policies. You get four insurance plans, each with different perks:

The plan	The deductible	Rental fees	Gas reimbursement
The basic plan	$3000 deductible	Earn 85% of rental fees	65% gas reimbursement
The standard plan	$2500 deductible	Earn 80% of rental fees	80% gas reimbursement
The premium plan	$1000 deductible	Earn 75% of rental fees	85% gas reimbursement
The premium plus plan	$500 deductible	Earn 70% of rental fees	100% gas reimbursement

Eligibility Requirements for Turo and HyreCar

Both platforms have different eligibility requirements. Some are more restricting than others.

Turo’s Eligibility Requirements

To be eligible to rent a car from Turo, you need:

• A Turo account
• Driver’s license number (Valid permanent license for U.S. citizens)
• Personal photo
• Payment method
• A home Address
• To be at least 21
• Auto insurance score (for U.S. citizens)

HyreCar’s Eligibility Requirements

HyreCar has different eligibility requirements. These include:

• A valid social security number
• A driver’s license
• One year of driving experience (for people between the ages of 21-24)
• Three months of driving experience (for people 25+)
• Clean criminal record
• Passing a motor vehicle record check

Note: Your car also needs to pass the Hyrecar vehicle requirements.  

Pros and Cons of HyreCar

Now that you understand the main differences between both platforms, let’s get into the pros and cons of each.

Pros of HyreCar

HyreCar is a big company for a reason. It offers various benefits to ensure you have a safe, smooth rental experience.

Eliminates Fake Listings

If you’ve ever rented a car before, you probably know that fake listings are all over the internet. Well, you don’t have to worry about that anymore.

Here’s how Hyrecar works: Once a car owner makes a listing, the company workers contact and question them to ensure it’s not fake.

Only Allows Legit Drivers

Yes, the company runs background checks for the renters, searching for criminal records, credit scores, driving records, etc. You might think that’s too inconvenient, as it makes the renting process take longer.

Think of it this way: It shows the platform is serious about offering the most legit renting experience. Besides, the background check only takes a few hours, which isn’t that long.

No Strings Attached

HyreCar understands that first-time drivers will be hesitant to use their services. That’s why it doesn’t require long-term commitment.

You can rent a vehicle for a couple of days (the minimum rental duration) to test the water. If you enjoy the service, you can extend the rental period for as long as you like, whether it’s by a day, a week, or a month.

Cons of HyreCar

HyreCar isn’t a perfect company. Like any other service, you’re bound to face a few issues.

Run-Down Cars

We’re not saying that all the cars in their platforms are run-down. Remember, HyreCar targets rideshare drivers.

These people rent cars intending to achieve long-term mileage. Chances are: The platform’s cars won’t be in premium condition.

Pros and Cons of Turo

If HyreCar is such a convenient platform, how does Turo compare?

Pros of Turo

We can dedicate an entire post to Turo’s pros, but we’ll try to make this concise.

You Know What You’re Getting

We know how hard it is to know the exact model you’re getting with car rental companies. You don’t have to worry about that with Turo. The car you clicked on is the one you’re getting.

Fancy Cars

Turo isn’t a traditional car rental company with an inventory of regular cars. It offers the most luxurious brands on the market, from Porsche and Lamborghini to Ferrari and Tesla.

Cons of Turo

Now that you know the benefits of using Turo, let’s see some of the drawbacks.

Young-Driver Fee

A young-driver fee is an additional cost that Turo charges if you’re under 25. It usually ranges between $30-50.

Here’s the problem; Some people have reported paying that fee despite being 25, so you want to look out for that.

Making the Decision: Factors to Consider

Now that we’ve covered the pros and cons of both companies, it’s time to choose a winner.

Here’s the catch: There isn’t one. Ultimately, your decision should depend on your needs and which platform caters to them more.

1. Intention

As you know by now, both companies have different target audiences. If you’re looking to secure a rental vehicle to earn extra cash doing deliveries, HyreCar is your best bet.

If you want it for personal use, Turo has got you covered.

2. Costs

Costs can’t be a decisive factor in deciding which platform is suitable for you. Both platforms have similar prices, though.

HyreCar

The average rate in Hyrecar is $30-40 a day. Unfortunately, there’s more to the total price than the daily rate of the car. You also pay 15% of the rate as a transaction fee and $18 for insurance.

Turo

Turo might be on the pricier side, which is natural, given that it offers more premium cars. The average daily rate of Turo’s cars is $50-100. You also pay a trip fee, which differs depending on your trip.

There are more fees included too, such as a cancellation fee and, in some cases, a security deposit. As such, the cost of Turo cars is on the high end, so make sure they’re worth it.

Wrapping Up

By now, you should know the differences between HyreCar and Turo. Ultimately, both platforms target different audiences and offer different experiences.

HyreCar is more effective for a longer rental duration with no fake listings. Turo is more suitable for a weekend trip with your friends and loved ones.